• Home
  • About

Rural Ruminations

OpEd pieces by a retired CIA station chief.

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« Pentagon Isn’t Necessarily a Better Option Than the CIA
Politics dictates withdrawal from Iraq »

Iraq Withdrawal isn’t an Option, Change in Policy is a Must

June 5, 2005 by Haviland Smith

[Originally published in the Valley News.]

Falling poll numbers for the president and Congress and growing discontent with the Iraq war have breathed new life into what was recently a moribund anti-war movement. This will certainly bring joy to those who oppose all wars on moral grounds, but American pragmatists might better look more deeply into the potential outcomes of an early and precipitous American withdrawal from Iraq.

The arguments for and against the invasion of Iraq have been made. The invaders won, despite considerable evidence that argued, apparently correctly, against that invasion. But only history will ultimately show whether the decision to invade was folly or genius.

The fact is that we did invade and, right or wrong, we are now stuck with the reality of having dropped the plate at Pottery Barn. The only thing that is truly important for America right now is to sort out our future Iraq policy on the basis of today’s facts — and on the national interests of our country.

Iraq probably was never meant to be a country and has never been inherently stable. It is populated by people who share little in common. Sunnis, Kurds and Shiites have coexisted with minimal peace only because it was forced on them by a strong, ruthless and murderous central government.

Even more important, those disparate constituencies have supporters elsewhere in the region. The Saudis and other Sunni governments support the Sunnis; the Iranians support the Shiites; and millions of fellow Kurds in Turkey, Iran, Syria and Central Asia support the Kurds. None of the region’s undemocratic countries is likely to welcome a truly representative Iraqi democracy into their midst. Further, even democratic Turkey has major reservations about the creation of any kind of autonomous Kurdish Iraq, fearing its potential influence over a widely discontented Turkish Kurdish population. Iraqi Shiites have Iran as their main ally, and Iran is no friend of our Middle East policies. It is almost certainly not in the self-interest of those undemocratic regimes to support self-determination in Iraq.

Through our invasion, America has taken over the mantle of power from the Saddam Hussein regime. It is probable that age-old hostilities among Shiites, Sunnis and Kurds have not emerged more violently only because we are there in the position of enforcer. To test that probability by pulling out would be folly.

What do we want for Iraq, and what can we reasonably hope for? The only realistic answer is simple: We want stability because instability would most likely involve far too many other nations in the region. Iraq will probably not emerge as a recognizable democracy, but if we do it right, stability there will flow from self-determination.

We want to leave an Iraq that is stable on its own terms rather than ours ó not necessarily in deference to Iraqi sensibilities, but in recognition of our own self-interest. Perhaps this can be achieved through an Iraq government that is a federation. Such a government would grant autonomy to the three major groups, but would not be fragmented to the point where the central government was in danger of losing control over its territory, bringing civil war, regional unrest and even more terrorists than we are creating with our current policies. None of this may work, but we have to try.

For any new policy to work, the Bush administration needs to start out by acknowledging that things are not going well, by making the case that changes must be made and by explaining why Americans need to support that change. Once Americans understand and sign on, we will need to enlist the support of other nations and entities such as NATO in the training of Iraqi police and military personnel. Finally, we need to say clearly that we have no plans to establish U.S. bases, reserve oil rights or make any other sort of claim on Iraq.

Of course, the ultimate question is whether the Bush administration is up to the task, politically or psychologically. After all, it does not have a good record of admitting it was ever wrong about much of anything.

This is a time for patience. Our 2003 invasion is history. We need to develop a plan for establishing stability in Iraq and stick with it. A precipitous withdrawal would likely be a disaster, not only in Iraq, but throughout the Middle East, causing far more problems for us in the long run.

Haviland Smith is a retired CIA station chief who served in Beirut and Tehran and as chief of the counterterrorism staff.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in foreign policy, Iraq |

  • Search all posts

  • Newest Posts

    • TRUMP AT WAR WITH AMERICA
    • WHERE IS THE WORLD HEADED?
    • Democratic socialism and the coming election
  • Posts by Category

    • Afghanistan (34)
    • CIA (23)
    • Democracy (7)
    • Egypt (6)
    • foreign policy (104)
    • Gulf (1)
    • Insurgency (3)
    • intelligence (22)
    • Iran (18)
    • Iraq (44)
    • ISIS (1)
    • Israel/Palestine (27)
    • Lebanon (2)
    • Libya (2)
    • Middle East (60)
    • Military Polilcy (8)
    • NATO (1)
    • Pakistan (2)
    • Revolution (2)
    • Russia (20)
    • Syria (11)
    • terrorism (53)
    • Uncategorized (25)
    • United States (88)
    • Yugoslavia (4)
  • Posts by Date

    • March 2020 (2)
    • February 2020 (1)
    • September 2019 (2)
    • August 2019 (5)
    • February 2018 (2)
    • January 2018 (1)
    • December 2017 (1)
    • October 2017 (1)
    • September 2017 (1)
    • June 2017 (1)
    • May 2017 (2)
    • April 2017 (1)
    • March 2017 (2)
    • February 2017 (3)
    • January 2017 (1)
    • November 2016 (1)
    • October 2016 (1)
    • June 2016 (4)
    • February 2016 (1)
    • December 2015 (1)
    • October 2015 (1)
    • September 2015 (1)
    • August 2015 (4)
    • May 2015 (1)
    • March 2015 (1)
    • February 2015 (1)
    • November 2014 (1)
    • August 2014 (1)
    • June 2014 (1)
    • May 2014 (1)
    • February 2014 (1)
    • December 2013 (1)
    • November 2013 (1)
    • August 2013 (3)
    • July 2013 (1)
    • June 2013 (1)
    • May 2013 (1)
    • March 2013 (4)
    • February 2013 (2)
    • January 2013 (2)
    • December 2012 (2)
    • November 2012 (1)
    • October 2012 (1)
    • September 2012 (2)
    • August 2012 (1)
    • July 2012 (1)
    • June 2012 (1)
    • May 2012 (1)
    • March 2012 (4)
    • February 2012 (1)
    • January 2012 (1)
    • December 2011 (1)
    • November 2011 (3)
    • October 2011 (3)
    • September 2011 (2)
    • August 2011 (2)
    • July 2011 (2)
    • June 2011 (3)
    • May 2011 (3)
    • April 2011 (4)
    • March 2011 (3)
    • February 2011 (2)
    • January 2011 (4)
    • December 2010 (3)
    • November 2010 (3)
    • October 2010 (2)
    • September 2010 (4)
    • August 2010 (3)
    • July 2010 (4)
    • June 2010 (4)
    • May 2010 (3)
    • April 2010 (2)
    • March 2010 (4)
    • February 2010 (3)
    • January 2010 (6)
    • December 2009 (4)
    • November 2009 (3)
    • October 2009 (3)
    • September 2009 (3)
    • August 2009 (1)
    • July 2009 (4)
    • June 2009 (4)
    • May 2009 (3)
    • April 2009 (3)
    • March 2009 (4)
    • February 2009 (4)
    • January 2009 (6)
    • December 2008 (4)
    • November 2008 (2)
    • October 2008 (3)
    • September 2008 (6)
    • August 2008 (5)
    • July 2008 (7)
    • June 2008 (2)
    • May 2008 (5)
    • April 2008 (2)
    • March 2008 (3)
    • January 2008 (1)
    • December 2007 (1)
    • November 2007 (3)
    • September 2007 (2)
    • August 2007 (2)
    • July 2007 (2)
    • June 2007 (2)
    • May 2007 (1)
    • April 2007 (1)
    • March 2007 (2)
    • February 2007 (1)
    • January 2007 (1)
    • December 2006 (1)
    • November 2006 (1)
    • September 2006 (1)
    • August 2006 (1)
    • July 2006 (2)
    • June 2006 (1)
    • May 2006 (3)
    • April 2006 (1)
    • February 2006 (1)
    • January 2006 (1)
    • November 2005 (1)
    • September 2005 (1)
    • August 2005 (1)
    • June 2005 (1)
    • April 2005 (1)
    • March 2005 (1)
    • January 2005 (2)
    • December 2004 (1)
    • November 2004 (1)
    • September 2004 (1)
    • August 2004 (1)
    • May 2004 (1)
    • April 2004 (2)
    • November 2003 (1)
    • October 2003 (1)
    • August 2003 (1)
    • June 2003 (1)
    • February 2003 (1)
    • January 2003 (2)
    • December 2002 (1)
    • January 2002 (1)
    • November 2001 (1)
    • September 2001 (1)
    • August 2000 (1)
    • January 2000 (1)
    • August 1999 (1)
    • May 1999 (1)
    • August 1998 (1)
    • April 1997 (1)
    • August 1996 (1)
    • July 1995 (1)
    • January 1995 (1)
    • September 1994 (1)
    • March 1994 (1)
    • October 1992 (1)
    • July 1992 (1)
    • February 1992 (1)
    • August 1991 (1)
    • February 1991 (1)
  • Videos

    • Haviland Smith: VPT Profile
    • The Impact of the U.S. Invasion and Occupation of Iraq
  • RSS

    • RSS - Posts
  • Blog Counter

    • 6,724 pages viewed

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

WPThemes.


Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • Rural Ruminations
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Rural Ruminations
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
%d bloggers like this: